February 20, 2001

TO:
JCPA Member Agencies
FROM:

Martin J. Raffel, Associate Director,

RE:
World Alliance of YMCAs "Palestine" Report

BACKGROUND:

As you may know, the World Alliance of YMCAs, based in Geneva, has posted a 3000-word report based on a five-day visit to "Palestine," concluding that "the one-sided nature of the conflict demands that the YMCA take the side of the oppressed Palestinian people." 

Kenneth Gladish, national executive director of YMCA of the USA, has written a letter to Geneva distancing his group from the World Alliance report.  He wrote that "The language, tone, and characterizations included in [the report] do nothing to aid the the true cause of peace and stability, nor do they posiiton the YMCA for effective service across the boundaries of dispute."

ACTION:

A number of JCPA member agencies have issued statements congratulating the YMCA of the USA for protesting the biased report issued by the International YMCA Organization.  Copies of the statements issued by the ADL and the AJCongress follow.  We encourage your membership to write to Kenneth Gladish at the YMCA of the USA to thank and commend him for his position on this matter.  He can be reached at the following address:

Dr. Kenneth L. Gladish National Executive Director YMCA of the USA 101 North Wacker Drive Chicago, IL 60606

ADL Commends YMCA of the USA for Protesting Biased Report Issued by International YMCA Organization 

New York, N.Y., February 16, 2001 ... The Anti-Defamation League (ADL) today commended the YMCA of the USA for protesting the biased, one-sided report on the Palestinians, issued by the world body of YMCA, that excluded the Israeli perspective on the ongoing conflict. "We commend Kenneth Gladish, Executive Director of the YMCA of the USA, for speaking out against this biased, anti-Israel report and distancing his organization from it," said Abraham H. Foxman, ADL National Director. "To release a report that does not mention Palestinian violence or concern for Israeli victims, under the auspices of the international YMCA, provokes the situation more than subdues it. We encourage other members of the international YMCA to follow the lead set by the USA and speak out against this document." Mr. Gladish, in a letter to the international YMCA, protested the "language, tone and characterizations" of the report, which refers to the land as "Palestine" and not Israel, and said it "can serve only to inflame the long-standing tensions in the region." The Anti-Defamation League, founded in 1913, is the world's leading organization fighting anti-Semitism through programs and services that counteract hatred, prejudice and bigotry.


AJCONGRESS CONGRATULATES YMCA OF THE USA FOR ITS CRITICISM OF ISRAEL-BASHING REPORT OF THE INTERNATIONAL YMCA ORGANIZATION

(February 16, 2001) The American Jewish Congress today congratulated the YMCA of the USA for its criticism of the report of the Geneva-based World Alliance of YMCA's which blames Israel exclusively for the violence in the region, and which states that "the one-sided nature of the conflict demands that the YMCA take the side of the oppressed Palestinian people." AJCongress refers to the report as an "anti-Israel diatribe" and a "document so flawed that in the minds of all fair-minded people it can only serve to tarnish the reputation of the organization that produced it."

In a letter to Executive Director Kenneth Gladish of the Chicago-based YMCA of the USA, AJCongress Executive Director Phil Baum declared that Gladish was "right on the mark" when he stated, "The language, tone and characterizations (of the report) do nothing to aid the true cause of peace and stability, nor do they position the YMCA for effective service across the boundaries of the dispute. These documents are inappropriate and can serve only to inflame the long-standing tensions in the region." In the face of criticism, the international group has acknowledged on its website that the observers it sent "for reasons of time and circumstances did not also visit Israel." "Tendentious and biased accounts such as the report of the World Alliance can only encourage the Palestinian Authority in its support of violence against Israel," Baum wrote to Gladish. "Your letter provides hope to the anguished people of Israel that they are not alone in their struggle to live in peace with their Palestinian neighbors, and that organizations such as the YMCA of the USA recognize that fair-mindedness, openness to the truth and a rejection of prepared a priori conclusions is the only way to advance the cause of justice for all of the peoples in the Middle East."

The American Jewish Congress, founded in 1918 by Rabbi Stephen S.Wise, Justice Louis D. Brandeis and other distinguished Jews, specializes in combatting all forms of bigotry through law and legislation. Considered the legal voice of the American Jewish Community, it works to safeguard Jewish interests, protect basic freedoms enshrined in the American Bill of Rights and to advance the security of Israel.